Ollie Persey of the Garden Court Education Law Team, instructed by Karen May of Bindmans LLP, acted for the successful Claimant.
On 17 November 2026, the High Court quashed Essex County Council’s decision to change a disabled 15-year-old girl’s home-to-school transport times, and ordered a further assessment.
Background
The Claimant, a fifteen-year-old girl, was receiving an Education, Health and Care Plan (‘EHCP’) and had special educational needs, including sensory needs. Her transport had previously dropped her off before the school day began, and collected her before the end of the day, as she encountered dysregulation in busy and crowded spaces.
In September 2025, the Council decided to shift the transport to later times, despite a faculty member stating that arriving with crowds had previously left the Claimant dysregulated and unable to access her education.
The Council refused her appeals on the basis that what happens once a child arrives at school is not a transport issue. The Claimant’s mother had subsequently paid for transport out of her own limited resources, which she stated was unaffordable long-term as she is on benefits.
The Claimant’s mother brought the claim for her child as a litigant in person in February 2026 and independently obtained permission for judicial review. The legal team narrowed the claim to a single ground: that the decision was irrational and in breach of the Council’s duty under Section 508B of the Education Act 1996.
The judgment
The Judge held that suitable transport is about access to education. That includes not only getting a child to school for the start of the school day, but also the child’s ability to engage with and benefit from the education on offer (see paragraph [42] judgment). The Judge found that, by focussing only on the journey and the moment of arrival, the Council lost sight of that purpose. It treated the evidence about timings as a “nice to have” when it in fact went to the heart of suitability (at paragraphs [46]-[47] of the judgment).
The Court found the Council also erred in three other significant ways:
- They read the statutory guidance as requiring a medical reason for different timings, when a medical condition is only one example of why a child may require adjustments (at paragraph [48] of the judgment);
- They treated the claimant’s request as one to attend school outside school hours for extracurricular activities, which the Judge agreed was “obviously wrong” (at paragraph [49] of the judgment); and
- They said that the school could provide the necessary buffer instead, with no evidence of how this could be achieved when the proposed ten-minute window left no time to spare (at paragraph [50] of the judgment).
The Judge refused to withhold relief under s.31(2A) Senior Courts Act 1981, quashed the decision and directed the Council to reassess the Claimant’s transport needs (at paragraph [54]-[55] of the judgment).
Implications of SKM
The judgment confirms that drop-off and pick-up times ought to be part of an assessment of whether home-to-school transport is suitable. In general, separate arrangements remain the exception and must be justified in each individual case. However, families seeking different times can explain how this helps the child manage the compulsory school day, and should support this with evidence (e.g. the EHCP, a letter from the school and professional reports). A medical reason is not necessarily required.
Councils must engage properly with evidence about how transport arrangements affect a child’s learning after arrival. Ultimately, the suitability of particular transport arrangements should be “assessed holistically by reference to the statutory purpose, which is to support the education of children with special educational needs who are at risk of missing out on their education.” (paragraph [42] of the judgment).
Full judgment: SKM, R (on the application of) v Essex County Council [2026] EWHC 2978 (Admin)
See Bindman’s press release here.










